City plans must be made to face problems of management, growth, and the evolution of a city. The planners cannot just work on day-to-day problems but must project into the future. They also look at planning entire regions rather than just cities. This is the job of people who work in urban planning.
Their main concerns are: - Maintaining or creating green spaces (ex: the green belt in London) which become the “lungs” of big cities. - Adapting infrastructure to traffic, supply, and waste management. - Renovating old neighbourhoods which tend to be in the centre of towns and which do not correspond to the requirements of a bigger town. - Anticipate the arrival of new inhabitants in the best possible conditions. Local town plans are put in place by the urban planners in collaboration with political institutions.
Urban planning case study: Barcelona before and after the 1992 Olympics
Case Study: Barcelona Before and After the 1992 Olympics Before the Olympics In the 1980s, Barcelona was an industrial city in decline. Many factories, especially in the Poblenou district, once known as the “Catalan Manchester”, had closed, leaving large areas of derelict industrial land. The city had turned its back on the sea: railway lines, warehouses and industrial sites separated the inhabitants from the coast, and the few beaches were polluted and neglected. Traffic was congested, and many neighbourhoods lacked public spaces and green areas. The Olympic Project When Barcelona was chosen in 1986 to host the 1992 Summer Olympics, the city used the Games as an opportunity to transform itself. Most of the investment went into urban infrastructure rather than sports facilities. The main projects were:
Opening the city to the sea: the coastal railway line was moved and partly buried, the industrial waterfront was cleared, and several kilometres of new beaches and a seafront promenade were created.
The Olympic Village (Vila Olímpica): built on former industrial land in Poblenou to house the athletes, then converted into a residential neighbourhood with a marina.
Ring roads (Rondes): new ring roads around the city reduced traffic in the centre.
Port Vell: the old port was redeveloped into an area for leisure, shopping and tourism.
Montjuïc: the hill was redeveloped as the main Olympic site, with the stadium and sports facilities.
Public spaces: many new squares, parks and green spaces were created across the city.
Modern infrastructure: the airport was extended and new telecommunications towers were built.
After the Olympics: Positive Effects
Barcelona became one of the most visited cities in Europe, and tourism became a major source of income and jobs.
Former industrial areas were regenerated. In 2000, the 22@ district was created in Poblenou to attract technology and innovation companies.
The inhabitants regained access to the sea and gained many new public spaces.
The “Barcelona Model” became an international example of how a major event can be used to regenerate a city.
After the Olympics: Negative Effects
Gentrification: property prices and rents rose sharply, especially in the redeveloped areas, forcing many lower-income residents to move out.
Overtourism: the huge number of tourists has caused overcrowding, noise and tension with local residents, and many apartments have been turned into tourist rentals. Residents have organised protests against mass tourism, and the city has announced plans to phase out tourist apartment licences by 2028.
Some critics argue that the transformation mainly benefited investors and visitors rather than the original inhabitants.
Conclusion Barcelona shows how a major event can be used as a catalyst for large-scale urban planning, transforming a declining industrial city into a modern, attractive metropolis. However, it also shows the limits of such projects: success can create new problems, such as gentrification and overtourism, which require further planning.
Urban Planning in Switzerland
Goals According to Article 75 of the Federal Constitution, spatial planning must ensure an economical use of land and an orderly settlement of the country. The Federal Spatial Planning Act (Loi sur l’aménagement du territoire, LAT), in force since 1980, sets out the main goals:
protecting the natural foundations of life: soil, air, water, forests and landscape
keeping building zones separate from non-building zones
preserving enough good agricultural land
creating compact settlements and avoiding urban sprawl
promoting balanced development between regions, so that peripheral and mountain areas are not left behind
ensuring good locations for housing, jobs, transport and public facilities
Who Does What? Spatial planning is shared between three levels, in line with Swiss federalism. The Confederation
sets the principles through the Constitution and the LAT
produces sectoral plans for its own fields: transport, military areas, aviation, power lines, and the protection of the best agricultural land
approves the cantonal structure plans
The Cantons
are mainly responsible for spatial planning
each canton must draw up a cantonal structure plan (plan directeur cantonal), which sets out how the canton’s territory should develop over the next 20–25 years: where towns should grow, main transport links, areas for industry, landscapes to protect, and so on
the structure plan is binding on the authorities (Confederation, canton and communes) but not directly on landowners
it must be approved by the Federal Council
The Communes
draw up the land-use plan (plan d’affectation, often called the plan de zones), together with building regulations
the land-use plan divides the commune’s territory into zones:
building zones: residential, industrial, mixed, and zones for public buildings such as schools and hospitals
agricultural zones: where only farm buildings are normally allowed
protection zones: for nature, landscapes and heritage
it sets precise rules: building heights, distances between buildings, alignments, and the services that must be provided (roads, sewers, water, electricity)
it is adopted by the communal council or by the voters, approved by the canton, and binding on everyone, including landowners
building zones may only cover the needs of the next 15 years
Communes can also work together on regional plans, which is especially useful in agglomerations that spread across several communes. Some cantons also ask their communes to draw up a communal structure plan, setting out the commune’s general development goals.
Building Permits Every new building or major renovation requires a building permit. The commune or canton checks that the project respects the land-use plan and building regulations. Projects are made public, and neighbours or organisations can file an objection and, if needed, appeal to the courts.
Important Reforms
Second Homes Initiative (2012): accepted by voters, it limits second homes to 20% of the housing in each commune, to stop the uncontrolled building of holiday homes in tourist regions.
Revision of the LAT (2013): accepted by voters in March 2013, it aims to stop urban sprawl:
communes with oversized building zones must reduce them
towns must grow inwards (densification) rather than outwards, for example by building on brownfield sites or adding storeys
when farmland becomes building land and its value rises, the owner must pay a tax of at least 20% of the gain, used to compensate owners whose land is removed from building zones
Second stage of the revision (2023): adopted by Parliament, it aims to limit construction outside building zones.
The Interest and Limits of Urban Planning Why Is Urban Planning Necessary? Switzerland is a small country, and only about a third of its territory is suitable for settlement and farming, since much of the rest is mountains, lakes and forests. Without planning, towns would spread chaotically, the best farmland would disappear, and the costs of roads, sewers and public services would rise sharply. Planning makes it possible to:
use limited land economically
protect landscapes, nature and farmland
organise transport and public services efficiently
reduce risks by avoiding building in dangerous areas (floods, landslides, avalanches)
balance development between regions
Limits of Spatial Planning
Slow procedures: a large project can take years or even decades, because of planning procedures, objections and court appeals.
Federalism: Switzerland has more than 2,100 communes, each with its own land-use plan. Communes may compete to attract residents and companies, which does not always serve the interests of the whole region.
Property rights: land belongs mostly to private owners. If a plan reduces the value of someone’s land, for example by removing it from a building zone, the authorities may have to pay compensation, which makes such changes difficult and expensive.
Urban sprawl has continued: despite planning, the area covered by buildings and roads has grown by about a third since the mid-1980s.
Plans become outdated: plans are made for 15–25 years, but society changes faster, as shown by the rise of remote working and online shopping.
Land and housing prices: planning can influence where people build, but it cannot fully control land prices or rents.
Densification is unpopular: although building inwards is the official goal, neighbours often oppose taller buildings or new projects near their homes.
Conflicts of Interest in Urban Planning Every piece of land can only be used once, and different groups want to use it in different ways. Spatial planning must therefore balance conflicting interests. In Swiss law, the authorities must carry out a weighing of interests: they identify all the interests involved, assess their importance and choose the solution that best balances them.
The Main Actors Landowners, farmers, businesses, residents, environmental and heritage organisations, tourists, communes, cantons and the Confederation. Some environmental organisations have a legal right of appeal against projects that may harm nature or landscapes.
Main Conflicts Building vs. Agriculture Towns need land for housing and businesses, while farmers need fertile land to produce food. The best farmland is often on the flat Swiss Plateau, exactly where towns grow. The Confederation requires the cantons to protect about 440,000 hectares of the best farmland. Renewable Energy vs. Landscape and Nature Switzerland wants to produce more renewable energy, but projects often face strong opposition:
Wind farms are criticised for their impact on landscapes and birds. The Sainte-Croix wind farm (VD) took around 20 years from planning to construction because of appeals.
Large solar parks in the Alps produce a lot of electricity in winter, but they affect untouched mountain landscapes. Several projects have been rejected or scaled down, and in 2023 Valais voters rejected a decree meant to speed them up.
Raising dams for hydroelectric power can flood valleys and protected areas.
Transport vs. Environment and Quality of Life New roads and railways improve connections but take up land, divide landscapes and create noise. In November 2024, Swiss voters rejected a federal project to widen several sections of motorway. Densification vs. Heritage and Neighbours Building inwards protects farmland and limits sprawl, but taller buildings can change the character of a neighbourhood, reduce green spaces and block views. Protected townscapes listed in the Federal Inventory of Swiss Heritage Sites (ISOS) must also be preserved. Tourism vs. Local Population In mountain resorts, second homes for wealthy visitors drive up property prices, so local people can no longer afford to live there. Many second homes also remain empty most of the year (“cold beds”). This conflict led to the Second Homes Initiative in 2012. Airports vs. Residents Airports such as Zurich and Geneva are vital for the economy but create noise for thousands of residents. Flight paths over southern Germany have also caused a long dispute between Switzerland and Germany. Economy vs. Environment Companies want large, well-connected industrial zones, while environmental groups want to protect natural areas, rivers and groundwater.
Relevant exams: 2017a: LAT p. 7-8 2019b: Land planning p. 10-11 2020a: T/F Land use planning p. 2 2021a Urban geography p. 6-7 2024b Land use planning p. 12-14